About the Post

Author Information

Creativity coach, writing and creative process instructor, speaker, author of Around the Writer's Block: Using Brain Science to Write the Way You Want (Penguin/Tarcher 2012) and Dancing in the Dragon's Den (Red Wheel Weiser), Teaching Artist at the Loft Literary Center.

The Ultimate Tool for Getting Pantsers Through Their Resistance to Plotting: Guest Post by Joel D Canfield


Guest blogger Joel D Canfield

In Part 1 of this two-part guest post from Joel D Canfield, Joel highlighted the limitations of trying to write book-length prose SOLELY by the seat of your pants. In this post, he explains how he structures a story without losing the benefits of “pantsing.”

Joel is the author of fourteen books and the Someday Box blog for those who want to get a book out of the someday box and into the world. You can find more of Joel’s insights at www.somedaybox.com

In the previous post, “How My Writing Process Saved the Day“, I said:

“The planning process I’ve adopted allows me to skip back and forth at will between analytical structural planning and intuitive storytelling creativity during the early stages. Flashes of insight can be worked into a loose framework before it’s set in stone.

“And then, once the framework is solid, sensible, structurally sound, I can dive in every day, pantsing my way in a frenzy of emotional outpouring through each segment the plan calls for.”

If that sounds good to you, here’s how I make it happen.

Finding the Hero’s 12 Waypoints

tightrope into tangle writer's block canstockphoto15437139The first piece of the puzzle was learning story structure from Larry Brooks.

Every long-form story shares the same structure. Every television drama or comedy, every movie, every novel, every memoir has some version of these 12 waypoints:

  1. It begins with a hook to get you interested,
  2. then spends time in some setup to invest you in the protagonist
  3. whose world turns upside down in an important first plot point
  4. and so the hero spends time flailing and failing in response
  5. during which we see the antagonist, raw and threatening, in a first pinch point.
  6. At the midpoint our hero learns or gains something and stops failing and
  7. starts gaining ground in their attack on the challenge.
  8. Once again we see the villain clearly in a second pinch point
  9. and 3/4 of the way through our story, it appears all is lost when our hero discovers that everything they’ve believed about the challenge is wrong
  10. until a second plot point gives our hero the information they need to dive into the
  11. climax of the story, the final chase scene or problem-solving process which leads to
  12. the final resolution and our happily ever after—or not.

If you’re familiar with Joseph Campbell and Christopher Vogler’s work regarding the Hero’s Journey, those will look familiar.

My first rudimentary story planning consisted of writing one sentence to describe each of those 12 elements. You can read more about that process at my website. I wrote more than one book using only those 12 sentences as a guide.

Laying the Foundation with Global Story Elements

tightrope web writer's block canstockphoto18200840When I discovered Shawn Coyne’s Story Grid I learned the value of clearly identifying other global story elements and points of specific movement. I’ll simply list these items; if you’d like an explanation of what each is and why it matters, I highly recommend reading the Story Grid blog or getting the book.

  • External Genre
  • External Value at Stake
  • Internal Genre
  • Internal Value at Stake
  • Obligatory Scenes & Conventions for the Genre
  • Point of View
  • Objects of Desire
  • Controlling Idea/Theme

Coyne calls the parts of the traditional three-act structure the Hook, Build, and Payoff. Each act needs these five parts:

  • Inciting Incident
  • Complication
  • Crisis
  • Climax
  • Resolution

Once I realized the value of having all this information figured out up front, I started filling in a Story Grid spreadsheet (see below) first, then going back to write my 12 sentences to describe the 12 waypoints above.

The two processes are complementary, so I end up going back and forth, applying something I discover in one to my work on the other. Nothing gets filled in sequentially. Plan for a messy, organic process at this phase, which can be fun for pantsers. Making the mess here reduces messes during writing.

There isn’t a 1-to-1 relationship between the 12 waypoints in my interpretation of the Hero’s Journey and the 15 elements of the Story Grid 3-act layout, but there are connections. For instance Waypoint #1, The Hook, matches the Inciting Incident of the Hook in the Story Grid spreadsheet, and the Crisis of the Story Grid’s Middle Build section is Waypoint #9, the All Is Lost Moment.

Here’s the 3-act overview spreadsheet for my work in progress. Note the brevity. Clarity here saves struggle later.

Adding the 8 global story descriptors and the 15 critical story movement elements from the Story Grid is exponentially more complex than planning with the 12 waypoint sentences alone. It is also exponentially more rewarding in both my planning process and my understanding of story. If your writing process allows you to work from the 12 sentences without using the Story Grid elements, apply the “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it” adage.

Listing the Scenes

tightrope steps writer's block canstockphoto19626243When I’ve identified my 8 global story descriptors and the 15 critical story movement elements from the Story Grid, and written the 12 sentences for the Hero’s Journey waypoints, I’m ready to write a scene list.

I’ve learned that my scenes average 1,000 words. Many writers average double that, but my brain thinks in smaller bits I guess. For my scene list, I arbitrarily decide how long I want the book to be (yes, I just make it up) and put that many lines on a new spreadsheet.

For my mysteries, I shoot for 64 scenes, 64,000 words. The time-traveling-Indiana-Jones scifi adventure I’m working on now needed to be longer, so I created a list of 100 scenes.

The story movement elements and journey waypoints fill in about 20 scenes in the new scene list spreadsheet. (The 12 sentences overlap the 15 Story Grid elements to some extent, which is why we get about 20 scenes rather than 27.)

Each of those scenes calls for other scenes to set them up or explain the fallout, which I add to the scene list spreadsheet. Some scenes naturally grow into entire sequences, small story arcs of three or more scenes tied together to deliver an important story point.

By the time I’m done jotting quick, high-level notes about all the scenes I know have to be written, I usually have about two-thirds of the scene list filled in.

The Rest of the Story

Subplots, logical deduction, and discoveries along the way fill in the rest of my scene list.

I always try to include at least one subplot, two if I can. One parallels the main plot in a minor fashion, tying into the main plot’s resolution near the end. The other is a mirror, the opposite of the main plot.

Once I get that far, I have very few holes in my scene list. Those fill themselves in as single scenes expand into two or three, or as other necessary scenes are discovered when I start pantsing my way through the first draft.

The scene list rescued me from the crisis I described in Part 1, wondering how a shift from a technical environment to an ancient jungle could make sense in my story.

Now the Hard Part Isn’t as Hard

tightrope in the clear rev writer's block canstockphoto19761696Once I have the list, I do what most writers consider the hard part: I sit down, every weekday, and write.

I usually start with a single scene per day, but before long I’m writing two or three, and as I near the end, I’ll write 4,000-5,000 words a day in a race with my hero to the end of the book.

Because I did the hard work of finding the story’s structure and creating a plan, getting words out every day isn’t the struggle it used to be. There are still days I have to fight resistance to sit down and do it, and days I’m not sure where I’m going or what I’m doing. Those are the days I have to trust that I knew what I was doing when I created the plan.

It’s not magic. It doesn’t take the work out of writing. It allows me to do the hard work at the right times, and to use the correct side of my brain for each part of the writing process.

When I’m confused or stuck, I know what to do. It’s right there in the plan.

Joel D Canfield writes literary noir mysteries he calls Chandleresque introspectives. He recently started experimenting with writing his first reading love, scifi adventure. Read about his books at http://JoelDCanfield.com and his indie author consulting at http://SomedayBox.com.

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

10 Comments on “The Ultimate Tool for Getting Pantsers Through Their Resistance to Plotting: Guest Post by Joel D Canfield”

  1. Whetstone August 5, 2017 at 6:00 am #

    Reblogged this on WHETSTONE and commented:
    For the pansters out there, this is a flexible, easily digestible plot structure for your long work (especially novel length).


  2. alomien May 1, 2016 at 11:27 am #

    Reblogged this on La Belle Epunque.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. lynnefavreau April 28, 2016 at 1:50 pm #

    Thanks Joel. I like the way you connect the plotting–both your method and Shawn’s Story Grid. Learning other writer’s process is invaluable. All writers should develop a process they can trust.

    Liked by 3 people

    • Joel D Canfield April 28, 2016 at 2:02 pm #

      I came to art from a very analytical perspective. My first love was math, not writing. My first drawings were architectural and my first writing was nonfiction.

      Once I got out of my own way and started writing music, fiction followed quickly, and it was a surprise to me how little I used my analytical brain in the early days of my art.

      The pendulum swings wider and wider.

      Liked by 2 people

  4. rachaelestout April 28, 2016 at 11:02 am #

    Great post as always Joel!

    I especially like how you write a sentence for each of the waypoints- it seems quite effective. Having several friends who fly by the set of their pants and go through several rewrites, I agree that some sort of planing before hand is essential.

    Generally I block out a few words for each scene. For me I like the exercise of finding the characters ‘shining moments’: I write three points where each character will look the best and then weave that into the scenes. As I write the world gets more solid and I can insert more or tweak as necessary.

    Liked by 2 people

    • Joel D Canfield April 28, 2016 at 12:11 pm #

      I like that idea. I’m a huge fan of leaving as much to serendipity as possible, without killing myself with unnecessary confusion and rework.

      Liked by 2 people

  5. Joel D Canfield April 28, 2016 at 9:54 am #

    Thanks again for hosting me, Rosanne.

    Liked by 1 person


  1. Getting Pantsers Past Their Resistance to Plotting - November 30, 2016

    […] Part II of my long post is live at the Bane of Your Resistance blog today. […]


  2. The Ultimate Tool for Getting Pantsers Through Their Resistance to Plotting: Guest Post by Joel D Canfield | Bane of Your Resistance | Odd Sock Proofreading & Copyediting - April 30, 2016

    […] Source: The Ultimate Tool for Getting Pantsers Through Their Resistance to Plotting: Guest Post by Joel D Ca… […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: